How Campfire Experiences Scale to Build Real Community Connection

How do intimate experiences that we call "campfire experiences" scale up to create connectedness across larger associations, organizations, or bigger?

Let's discuss how these small private moments are fundamental building blocks for a larger community. They're not an wholly separate investment when connecting large groups, organizations, or a culture.

The Arena-Campfire Distinction

We must recognize two importantly different types of events. Each serve their own purposes in the broader experience of knitting human connection in community.
Arena events are what most Americans think of when they think of the kind of gatherings that "connect people". They are large gatherings where participants face someone at the front in a big space together.

There's shared attention, collective focus, even a unified experience. These are not bad. They serve a purposes. They're just not events where individuals feel seen and understood by peers with whom they grow trust.

Then there are campfire experiences.
Intimate.
Usually conversational.
Personal.
People face each other rather than a stage.
These aren't competing approaches.
They can and often should be combined with powerful effect.

The Art of Combination

Imagine: an event begins with twenty or thirty minutes of arena experience.
Everyone gathered, sharing a common focus, hopefully sharing excitement and interest.
Then, intentionally and thoughtfully, the large group breaks into smaller experiences, "campfire experiences."

The arena event provides a shared experience with perhaps some spectacle.
The campfire experience gives participants a venue to notice that others share their value(s) or purpose(s) for joining in. At the campfire, they get evidence that others understand them both intellectually and emotionally. This is a big part of growing a feeling of connection with others.

Scaling Through Multiplication, Not Addition

There's another strategy we can use to scale. We can create multiple campfire experiences within a single space.
Imagine a beach barbecue designed with conventional thinking.
We'll find big circles of chairs set. They may even get set around a central cooking fire.
Everyone is faced toward the same focal point.
The conventional logic is obvious: bring everyone together.
Imagine the same event set up by someone who understands that we need intimate experiences where possibly vulnerable conversations can emerge.
Instead of one large circle or several large groups, you'll find seating arranged in small groups of five or fewer.
This is the size experience where deep trusting friendships are formed.
Multiple conversation spaces give participants a chance to find or create an intimate experience, whether they know they're seeking that for connection or not.
Several intimate gatherings can happen simultaneously.
The difference isn't experienced just intelectually. It's experienced emotionally.

The Magic of Small Numbers

Groups of two and three are fantastic for building genuine connection.
When you think about the friends you'd actually call when there is a crisis in your life, the friendships were almost certainly forged in small, intimate experiences.
Maybe in a car.
Maybe over coffee.
Maybe in those unstructured moments between formal activities.
There's also strategic wisdom in designing for groups of three rather than pairs.
If someone is distracted by a family emergency or personal crisis, their conversation partner has another person to still meaningfully connect to.
This way, we can allow participants to get distracted by life and still give others an opportunity to connect where they seek it.

The Furniture Thinking

Here's a diagnostic that reveals whether someone understands actual community building instead of spectacle and audience. Just look at how they arrange the furniture.
If you arrive at an event that's promoted as a connection experience, and all you see is arena setup (example: rows of chairs facing a stage), you know the organizer has no real understanding of how people actually connect.
It's connection theater.
It might be well-intentioned theater, and it's theater nonetheless.
I've learned it often comes as an effort to create good visuals for later reports rather than good conditions for relationship growth.
Remember, the furniture reveals the organizer's real priorities.
Chairs in rows prioritize information transfer and visual spectacle.
Chairs in small groups prioritize conversation and mutual discovery.

The Soup and Bread Standard

I know of a multibillion-dollar global tech company struggling with the same isolation and disconnection that affects organizations worldwide.
Their natural instinct, given their resources and brand expectations, is to create spectacular events.
Something worthy of their reputation.
Something that would photograph well.
Something impressively produced.
But what they actually needed was remarkably simple. Soup and bread would make a big difference for them.
If their teams gathered for soup and bread on Tuesdays and Thursdays, just that, nothing more elaborate, their connection challenges would shift in powerful ways.
Not because soup and bread are magic. It's because sharing soup with future friends creates the conditions where real human connection naturally emerges.
Simple food.
Regular rhythm.
Unpretentious setting.
No agenda beyond nourishment and presence.
The company found this difficult to embrace.
It wasn't spectacular enough.
It wouldn't create compelling photographs.
It doesn't match their sophisticated brand image.
The story shares something about how we often approach community-building efforts as a culture. We mistake impressiveness with effectiveness.

The Ice Cream Strategy

Sometimes the most powerful community-building tools are almost embarrassingly simple.
As a documentary film producer with a wide-spread team working with me, I used the campfire understanding to strengthen our team's bonds.
Whenever we experienced either a success or a failure worth acknowledging, I would distribute gift certificates to an ice cream chain.
They were big enough for two people to get generous ice cream together.
The instruction was simple: "Take someone else from the team and go celebrate."
They'd share time over ice cream
They'd have a private conversation about whatever they wanted to discuss.
They'd grow more connected.
The cost was exactly 2 ice cream desserts.
The whole experience combined recognition from leadership with an opportunity for private connection.
The celebration felt meaningful because it came from the boss.
The relationship deepened because two people spent unstructured time together.

The Lo-Fi Revolution

The most sustainable community-building strategies are often deliberately lo-fi.
When connection requires expensive venues or professional facilitation, it becomes fragile and or precious.
It depends on budgets and organizational priorities.
When connection requires nothing more than simple food or modest gift certificates, it becomes easy and more frequent.
Most importantly, it's replicable by community members themselves.

Creating Structures for Self-Organization

The ultimate goal isn't to create more events that you have to organize and manage.
The goal is to create a structure where participants can generate their own connection experiences.
This shifts your role from big event producer to pattern teacher.
Instead of asking "How can we bring everyone together?" you can consider "How can we enable people to bring themselves together?"
Instead of "What impressive thing can we organize?" you ask, "What simple thing can we facilitate that's fun and relevant?"

The Building Block Question

Large communities aren't built by scaling individual campfire experiences larger.
They're built by scaling campfire experiences more numerous.
We use arena events and experiences more preciously.
A healthy, large community is really a network of smaller, intimate communities.
Consider seeing it as multiple campfires instead of one enormous bonfire.
We want to encourage many intimate conversations rather than one massive presentation.
The arena serves its purpose, creating shared context, delivering information, and generating collective experience.
The campfire experiences do the actual work of community building. They create the relationships that sustain durable connection over time.

Practical Applications

This understanding has immediate practical implications for anyone responsible for bringing people together.
If you're planning a large event, consider building in deliberate transitions from arena to campfire experiences.
Start with shared inspiration or information.
Then create structured opportunities for small group interaction.
Ensure the break out time is how the majority of the gathered time is spent.
If you're designing ongoing community experiences, think in terms of enabling multiple small gatherings rather than fewer large ones.
Consider what the "soup and bread" equivalent might be in your context, something simple, regular, and naturally easy for conversation.
If you're trying to strengthen team connections, experiment with your version of the ice cream approach.
Find reasons to celebrate both successes and meaningful failures.
Provide simple ways for people to connect one-on-one or in very small groups.
Make these connections both voluntary and have the freedom to allow something meaningful to emerge.

The Deeper Pattern

Remember that lasting relationships form in small spaces, not large ones.
The path to widespread community runs through countless small conversations, not grand collective experiences.
We don't dismiss the value of large gatherings, shared rituals, or collective celebrations.
These serve essential functions in human social life.
If our goal is a genuine, durable connection, the kind that holds people up through challenges and enriches their daily life, we need to think carefully about offering conditions for intimate interaction.
Let's return to our generational understanding of how human beings have built lasting communities, one small gathering at a time, around shared warmth, in spaces safe enough for vulnerability and small enough for everyone to be seen.

Get free resources on building the community you long for at www.charlesvogl.com

Order the 2nd Edition with 25% new content