The Hidden Power of Your Community’s Origin Story
The Stories We Tell Influence Who Stays
Every community carries stories.
Some are spoken aloud often. Others only come up on special occasions. They all shape a community culture even if you don’t notice it.
When someone new visits, curious about whether you might be their person, they listen carefully even if they don’t realize it.
They listen for the values in the story.
They want to know what you think is important enough to share, celebrate, pass on, and emulate.
Why Stories Matter When Someone Is Deciding to Join
When someone considers joining a biking group, a podcasters’ group, or a circle of authors, their unspoken question is simple:
“Why these people and not others?”
Skills and resources might draw interest.
The stories grow commitment.
A potential member wants to understand:
What do you do here
What do you care about?
They learn it from the stories members tell.
Many communities never intentionally share the important stories for visitors to learn.
There’s no place to learn what shaped the group.
No moment to hear how it all began.
No resource that explains the deep inspiration that lead to gathering at all.
When these stories go missing, an opportunity to inspire new guests and allow them to recognize their own values among us is lost.
Origin Stories: The First Story People Look For
When people hear “origin story,” they often think of superheroes.
And that intuition is exactly right.
In every superhero story, what matters most is not the gained powers, it’s the motivation to use the power.
Two characters might have the same strengths. With different origin stories informing their fears, hopes, longings, and hurts, they become very different heroes.
The same is true in community building.
Your group might offer skills, resources, or access.
People want to know what values inform how you use all of these.
Are you mostly interested in bragging? Winning? Hoarding success? Or teaching, growing, preparing others and making your corner of the world safer?
What formed you?
Why did this community begin at all?
The Community Version of the Superhero Origin
A visitor will often like to know:
Was this group started to chase popularity or profit?
Did it begin because someone saw pain and wanted to help?
Did it start as a refuge? A movement? A rebellion?
Was it born from generosity or from fear?
Imagine two professional podcasting groups.
Group A began because members wanted to ride internet trends, grow audiences at any cost, and monetize quickly.
Group B began because someone saw people hurting and believed long-form conversation could bring wisdom and healing into the world.
Both groups may teach podcasting skills.
They do not share the same journey.
And the people who join don’t share the same aspirations.
Origin stories can serve as a filter: quietly, honestly, and powerfully.
They show a prospective member whether the community’s highest values align with their own.
Origin Stories Also Evolve and That’s Part of the Story
Communities change.
Sometimes dramatically.
Maybe the group began celebrating exclusion and competition, common in early-20th-century organizations.
Over time, leaders grew wiser.
Members pushed for generosity.
And today the community stands for something far more welcoming and flexible.
That transformation is also a story.
It can serve as a powerful one.
Telling the truth about where you began and how you changed helps members see:
how far you’ve matured
what values now matter more
why this group is worth investing in today’s reality
Origin stories don’t need to share perfect values, choices or people.
They need to be honest.
Seeing Ourselves in the Story
Strong origin stories allow people to see something of themselves:
A reflection of their values.
A mirror of their motivation.
A vision of the person they hope to grow into.
This is why Peter Parker’s story resonates differently than Superman’s.
And why the Hulk’s burden speaks to people who carry unseen battles.
Different origins pull different people.
Communities work the same way.
Feeling belonging grows when we recognize that values match.
The Question Every Leader Must Ask
If you’re building, nurturing, or stewarding a community, ask:
Where do people learn our origin story?
Is there a place where the story lives?
A ritual where it is shared?
A resource where new people can discover it?
If not, then consider where visitors want to learn your stories.
Get free resources on building the community you long for at www.charlesvogl.com
Order the 2nd Edition with 25% new content
