From Outsider to Elder: Understanding the Path Through Community Inner Rings

The Pursuit That Taught Me Everything

There's a chapter in my life where I was growing into a documentary filmmaker.  There was just about everything to learn. 

I recognize I was drawn to increasingly exclusive circles within the NYC documentary film world. I wanted to work with filmmakers who were now resourced by particular prestigious funders. I wanted to be a filmmaker, invited to the best film festivals. I wanted inclusion in a niche world that looked impossibly selective.

Each invitation to these inner rings felt like validation that I was maturing in some way. If this was actually true remained a question I'd reflect on. But the longing itself reflected something profound about how communities (in this case, a filmic arts community) actually work.

The Concentric Rings of Mature Communities

There was the vast outer ring of all wanna be filmmakers in America. Within that, a smaller circle of documentary filmmakers making professional-grade projects. Within that, a group funded by well-known organizations who support the best. Inside that, people who made PBS films for the most sought-after quality monikers. Then those whose PBS films screened in prestigious festivals. And at the center, filmmakers who won international awards and traveled the world with their work.

This architecture of inner rings appears everywhere once you start looking for it. Martial arts communities have their own concentric circles of mastery and recognition. Volunteer organizations develop natural hierarchies of commitment and responsibility. Even podcast networks create informal tiers of influence and access.

The pattern and structure itself is neither good nor bad. It simply is. The question we get to face is, how do we work with this natural pattern in ways that serve both individual growth and community health?

Why Boundaries Matter in Belonging

When I work with community builders now, we often clarify what I call the boundary principle. Communities need clear edges so important members recognize whether they're in or out. The same clarity grows important when we're thinking about inner rings in mature communities.

Consider cyclist James, who joins a cycling community. Either he gets invited to century rides in the Rocky Mountains, or he doesn't. This clarity eliminates the distracting uncertainty that plagues many communities. James knows what privileges he has access to. 

When members constantly wonder, "Can I be invited? How does one get invited? What are the unspoken rules?" frustration builds. The ambiguity itself becomes a problem, not the reality of different levels of involvement and permission.

The Essential Role of Elders

We need elders, people who've traveled the path earlier. They create or guide clear pathways for people with the right skills and values to progress.

If I have no idea how one gains access to those Rocky Mountain cycling adventures, my confusion can grow into resentment. When experienced cyclists share both the formal requirements and the informal wisdom needed to participate safely, the inner ring transforms into an aspirational invitation rather than a threatening exclusion.

This is where many communities fail. They create inner rings without creating pathways. They grow hierarchies without mentorship. They hold expertise without transmission opportunities.

The Currency of Esoteric Knowledge

One of the deepest satisfactions of belonging to a community with inner rings is gaining access to knowledge that exists nowhere else.

As a documentary filmmaker, I learned planning practices for international shoots that never surface in superficial conversation. I learned familiarity with intellectual property challenges that most Americans never discuss. I learned funding strategies and pitfalls that remained invisible to outsiders.

This knowledge came through spending time with more experienced filmmakers through extended relationships, not formal instruction alone. Real learning happened in the spaces between structured activities. This included over meals after screenings, during setup before shoots, in the quiet moments when pretension was gone and wisdom flowed naturally.

The Dance Between Documentation and Relationship

When designing healthy inner rings, we must balance formal structure with unpretentious, comfortable connection time.

Consider our hypothetical cycling community again. If there's an inner ring of people who tackle challenging Rocky Mountain rides, certain knowledge needs formal documentation: For example, safety protocols that keep everyone alive. Equipment requirements that ensure preparedness. Communication practices that maintain group focus.

Leaving essential safety information to chance would be irresponsible.

Deeper knowledge of reading weather patterns, managing group needs on difficult climbs, knowing when to push through discomfort and when to turn back, this wisdom transfers through relationships that spend unstructured time together. So shared experiences must be available. This includes learning through stories told at rest stops and subtle mentorship when experienced riders pack bags next to new riders.

The Digital Limitation We Must Acknowledge

The assumption that online platforms can replace the depth of connection that builds real community paves a road to disappointing disaster.

There's tremendous enthusiasm right now for digital solutions to seemingly everything. People expect webinars to create the relationships that previous generations built over shared meals. They hope online forums will transfer the knowledge that once flowed through apprenticeship.

Research consistently shows us that online connections serve as weak substitutes for in-person relationship building. They're not worthless, they have their place, but they're worth far, far less than face-to-face interaction when it comes to the deep transmission of wisdom and the formation of lasting bonds.

Creating Spaces for Transformative Connection

The communities that thrive understand this limitation and design accordingly. They create regular opportunities for people to gather in small groups. They prioritize the experiences that knit people together, the same bonding practices humans have used for millennia.

The esoteric knowledge of inner rings doesn't transfer well through bullet points and video tutorials. It emerges through shared challenges, through problem-solving together, through the informal moments when people let their expertise show naturally.

Practical Wisdom for Community Architects

If you're building or stewarding a community, start by observing the natural inner rings that already exist or want to emerge. They're probably already there, operating informally. Your job is to make them more visible and accessible.

When nurturing a mature community, map the knowledge, skills, and relationships that distinguish each broad level of involvement. Create clear criteria for progression while maintaining space for organic development. Document the foundational knowledge in accessible formats, the safety protocols and basic requirements. Design regular opportunities for cross-ring interaction time, especially between elders and emerging members.

Most importantly, resist the urge to flatten everything in service of some abstract ideal of equality. People don't just want to participate, they want to grow, to belong more deeply, to contribute in ways that match their evolving commitment and capability.

The Delicate Balance

Some communities thrive with precisely defined inner rings and advancement criteria. Others flourish with more fluid boundaries that clarify themselves as needs arise. Success depends on ensuring that members understand what's possible for them and how they might pursue deeper involvement and growth.

This requires ongoing attention and adjustment. It means regularly asking: Are our pathways clear? Are our elders participating in mentorship? Is knowledge flowing in ways that serve growth rather than hoarding?

Building for the Long Game

Inner rings, when designed with intention and care, create communities where wisdom flows naturally from experienced members to newcomers. They provide clear indicators of progress and belonging. They create aspirational pathways that motivate deeper engagement. Most importantly, they honor both the human need for inclusion and the equally human desire for meaningful progression.

My documentary filmmaking years taught me that people don't simply want access, they want the possibility of deeper access, earned through commitment, skill development, and contribution to something larger than themselves.

Communities that understand this create architecture of belonging that transforms casual participants into lifelong members, and eventually, into the elders who will guide the next generation through their own journey from outsider to insider to teacher.

Get free resources on building the community you long for at www.charlesvogl.com

Order the 2nd Edition with 25% new content