Initiation: The Missing Ritual of Modern Fandoms
We All Want to Know: Do I Belong Here?
Arguments over who’s a “real fan” come up around the world. One person insists they’ve been there since the beginning. Another says they promote the community, wear the gear, and bring new people in. This kind of exchange isn’t really about seniority or longevity. It’s about something much deeper: the human need to know, “When do I actually belong?”
Lack of Initiation Is a Problem
Every thriving community offers a clear way for someone to become part of it. Many modern fandoms and communities lack this clarity. There’s no rite of passage. No sacred moment of recognition. Without that moment, people remain unsure whether they are truly members or just tolerated guests. When this question lingers, it chips away at connection, trust, and a sense of identity.
Without Initiation, People Create Their Own
When a community doesn’t offer a clear initiation, people will try to invent one. They might show up consistently, take on responsibilities, or make sacrifices to prove their commitment. Even so, if no one explicitly recognizes their belonging, they continue to wonder. They hope someone notices. They need confirmation that their efforts mean something. And without that, even the most loyal contributors can still feel like outsiders.
The Twitch Story: Recognition Matters
Twitch once invited a group of content creators to become official partners. On paper, this was just a technical designation. It meant the platform would work with them more closely. That’s it.
Yet some of those creators cried when they received the invitation to the new identity. They had already been contributing for years. They were already loyal, active, and deeply engaged. Still, this official act of acknowledgment moved them deeply.
It didn’t change their work, and it didn’t change their level of involvement. It simply confirmed what they had long hoped was of course true, they belonged.
Communities don’t have to wait years to create that moment. We can do it now. It doesn’t require a contract or a spotlight. It just requires intention.
Initiation Is Simple. And It’s Sacred.
Initiation doesn’t have to be complex or dramatic. It use a token. A patch. A moment around a fire. These aren’t grand gestures. They simply officially mark a meaningful shift — the transition from visitor to honored contributing member.
Imagine trekking through the jungle with someone for several days. You deal with bugs, heat, exhaustion, and unknown terrain. Then, on the fourth day, your companion hands you the same hat they’ve used over the years on their sacred travels.
They say, “You’ve earned this. Use it to keep the sun off of you in faraway places.” That hat might be something you could buy online in a minute. Because of who gives it and why, it becomes sacred. It carries meaning that transcends price or usefulness.
Belonging Needs a Line. And It Needs a Moment.
People need a line to cross, and someone to welcome them across it. This is where initiation holds power. Tokens of belonging don’t have to be expensive. They have to be meaningful. They have to signify that a person has been seen, that their efforts and presence matter. Initiation rituals allow people to feel a shift that may have already taken place emotionally or spiritually. Now, it’s real and visible. It’s named.
Renewing Belonging Is Just As Important
Even long-time members need to be seen again. Just like couples renew their wedding vows, communities can create rituals that affirm someone’s long-term commitment. You don’t need to ask for renewed promises. You only need to mark the path you’ve walked together. A ten-year toast, a moment of shared silence, or the addition of a new stitch to an old token, each of these says, “You’ve stayed. And that matters.”
Reflection
Who in your community is waiting to feel seen? Who has been showing up, giving generously, and still wondering whether they truly belong? What small initiation can you offer today that would tell them they are no longer visitors, they are one of us?
Get free resources on building the community you long for at www.charlesvogl.com
